Home > Apologetics, General > Isn’t Christianity just wishful thinking?

Isn’t Christianity just wishful thinking?

I’ve seen this charge levied against Christians all the time. I think it’s very misguided, and I’ll briefly discuss four points, though more could be said.

My first and longest point is that we need to establish whether it’s wishful in the first place. I would maintain that atheism, for example, is just as wishful, if not more, when compared to Christianity. On atheism, mankind is pretty much the boss. We define our own good and we answer to no higher power, because after all, who wants to be subjected to authority? On atheism, no one has to give up their precious time by attending church, studying the Bible, or sharing the Gospel. You aren’t compelled to give your hard-earned money as offering. There are hardly any restrictions on sex or the number of sexual partners you can have. In fact, even secular psychologists have posited that the issue of sexual freedom is the biggest factor in people’s reluctance to accept certain religions. I don’t know if I’d wholly agree with that, but it’s hardly a trivial point. So with atheism, you’re the boss, you face fewer “restrictions,” you get to save your time and money, and you needn’t feel guilt over much at all besides big, obvious transgressions.

Christianity, by comparison, is decidedly inconvenient. You might argue, “But what could be better than the delusion that you’re going to eternal paradise after this life?” Well yes, that could be considered one of the “perks,” but you could just as easily point to clear indications that people prefer the NOW rather than the later. If everyone actually lived for their futures and subscribed to this way of thinking, you would probably see a lot more people studying much harder in school. After all, everyone knows that if you study harder, you’ll improve your chances of future success. You’d see people diligently watching what they eat, and exercising to prolong their lives. Sure, there is a minority subset of the population that does these things–whether religious or not–but it’s not a common trait. It takes above-average individuals to live this way, and judging by the vast numbers of Christians (many of whom are not exemplary in character or discipline on their own merits), you have to conclude that there’s more to belief than hoping for a nice future in the afterlife. In fact, I know a good number of Christians who earnestly say that they would believe and follow whether there was a heaven or not. In my earlier walk, this was hard to believe, but I can see the truth in that statement now.

Well, isn’t it wishful for Christians to think that their sins are all forgiven just by accepting Christ? Isn’t this a too-easy “get out of jail free” card? Only if you believe in the concept of sin in the first place, really. It’s more convenient to believe that sin doesn’t exist at all than to acknowledge it then seek forgiveness. Plus, TRUE Christianity is anything but easy.

Second, even if Christianity is more wishful than not, that does nothing to prove its falsehood. As William Lane Craig might put it, this is “Philosophy 101.” Namely, this is committing genetic fallacy because the origins of a conclusion do nothing to determine whether it’s true or not. What matters are things like proof and logic.

For example, people fervently hope that their loved ones will return safely from war. This has no bearing on the chances of survival for that loved one. The mere fact that it might be wishful doesn’t affect the probability of it being true.

Third, wishfulness could be attributed to pretty much any belief in existence today. As I mentioned, even atheism is not exempt from this. Something’s got to be right, and chances are, whatever’s right has some wishful elements to it. After all, there’s got to be some positives or benefits in it, right? So this charge of “wishful thinking” is just irrelevant.

Fourth and lastly, one might argue that wishful thinking will cause a person to stick to a belief despite evidence to the contrary. This may be the case sometimes, true. But again, changing one’s beliefs might just be trading in one set of perks for another. You could say this for holding to any position.

What this argument really boils down to is the ability to disprove Christianity in the first place. If you can show that its teachings are demonstrably false, but people are clinging to it out of wishful thinking, you’d have a more valid point here. In that case, you don’t even need to show that it’s wishful thinking because you’ve proved Christianity false on the merits of evidence and logic.

But honest atheists will admit that it cannot proved false, at least by any scientific means. So why bring up the “wishful thinking” claim in the first place? It’s like going in circles. You can only say “they believe because of wishful thinking” if you’ve shown the belief to be false beforehand.

Sorry, now I’m the one who might be going in circles…

Advertisements
  1. September 19, 2014 at 5:52 am

    search results rx toradol
    buy brand stromectol antibiotics in internet shop no
    prescription spain
    buy cheap Medrol online
    buy fda approved Dramamine
    vocal training exercises
    misoprostol with no prescription overnight
    shipping
    online letrozole fedex next day delivery
    Cytotec 100 mcg prescription
    i want a Suhagra prescription
    Valtrex 500 mg guaranteed delivery for
    robaxin-750 muscle sprains in internet pill priority mail
    buy valtrex at walmart
    price glucophage 10mg can you buy 850mg spain canada dpd online
    anti 500mg
    make money completing surveys
    online pharmacy micardis no prescription online prescription for micardis
    fda approved generic Medrol
    make cash taking surveys biz
    buy suhagra without perscription at Alabama
    zuma deluxe preise von Augmentin
    Beta blocker and tamsulosin
    Nexium generic order online
    get cash from a credit card
    billiger kaufen apotheke Lioresal anhalt
    buy express Calan
    Aricept online consultation overnight
    consegna Neurontin generico
    can i purchase lipothin online mastercard priority mail texas
    where to buy tamsulosin online canada
    Strattera 25 mg tablette
    how to get glucophage fedex visa connecticut
    buy discount methylprednisolone custom hrt
    nexium no prescription cod
    methylprednisolone by cod
    get now Floxin
    Dramamine lowest price
    where can i buy zithromax online next day shipping
    age to start singing lessons
    Buy misoprostol online
    fedex overnight methylprednisolone
    Dramamine fournir pour

  2. March 4, 2015 at 4:30 am

    You won’t be scratching your head so much as doing your best to not die.
    The open world nature meant a storyline with missions and freedom to roam in between (like GTA).
    If looking at the past i’d identify that before only a few
    folks played browsergames if we review the range that the overall participant
    add up is at now.

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: